After more than four years in business, Cohesive Strategy Group formally established its company values.
For a consulting firm that works with organizations to align leadership, culture, and strategy, that might seem unusual. Surely, a company that advises others about organizational culture should have established its own values from the beginning?
We deliberately took a different approach.
It wasn't that we operated without principles or beliefs about how we wanted to conduct business. Those existed from the outset. What we resisted was declaring those beliefs to be our company's values before we had the experience to understand which ones truly defined us.
Our philosophy is relatively simple: We believe organizations should value the things that make them successful. Not just the things they aspire to be, or the characteristics they believe a successful organization should possess.
We wanted to understand what made us effective, what our clients genuinely appreciated about working with us, and which behaviours had contributed to building a sustainable business. Only then could we confidently identify what we valued enough to preserve.
That experience reinforced a broader question we believe leaders should consider: Are organizational values something we should create, or something we should discover?
The Problem With How Organizations Establish Values
Establishing company values has become a familiar exercise in organizational development. A leadership team gathers, often with the assistance of a consultant or facilitator, and discusses the qualities it believes should define its organization. Through a process of discussion and refinement, a list emerges.
Integrity. Respect. Excellence. Collaboration. Innovation.
These are all admirable qualities. Few would argue against them. But if virtually every organization can claim the same values, what do those values actually tell us about the organization? More importantly, what evidence exists that these qualities genuinely define how the organization operates?
In his 2002 Harvard Business Review article, Make Your Values Mean Something, Patrick Lencioni challenged organizations to take their values more seriously. His concern was that poorly conceived values statements can undermine credibility when the behaviours of the organization fail to reflect what its leaders profess.
There is a fundamental difference between defining the organization you aspire to become and understanding the organization you have actually become. Both have value, but they are not the same thing.
More than two decades later, that challenge remains relevant. We regularly encounter organizations that have established values but struggle to explain how those values influence decisions or the everyday behaviour of employees. The values exist as statements of intent, but they are not necessarily reflected in the culture.
This is particularly challenging when organizations establish values before they have developed a meaningful operating history. Founders may know what they believe in and what kind of company they hope to build, but those beliefs have not necessarily been tested by the realities of running the business.
Your Organization Already Has Values, Whether You Have Written Them Down or Not
One of the most important things to understand about organizational culture is that it exists regardless of whether leadership has formally defined it. Every organization develops patterns of behaviour. People learn how decisions are made, what behaviours receive recognition, and what is tolerated. Over time, these patterns become established expectations.
This understanding is consistent with the work of organizational culture scholar Edgar Schein, who distinguished between an organization's espoused values and the deeper assumptions that influence how people actually behave. His work, discussed in this MIT Sloan retrospective, provides an important framework for understanding the difference between declared culture and lived culture.
An organization might claim collaboration as a core value while consistently rewarding individual achievement at the expense of teamwork. Another might promote accountability but allow senior leaders to avoid responsibility for their decisions. In both cases, the behaviours tell us considerably more about the organization's actual culture than its published values.
This is why we believe the process of establishing values should begin with understanding the culture that already exists. What behaviours are consistently demonstrated by the people who make the organization successful? What principles influence decisions when there is no policy or established procedure to follow? And when difficult choices arise, what does the organization actually prioritize?
The strongest evidence of what an organization values is found not in what it says, but in the behaviours it repeatedly demonstrates.
The answers often reveal the values an organization is already living, whether it recognizes them or not.
The challenge is that not every established behaviour is desirable. Some may have developed out of necessity, while others may reflect leadership practices that should have been challenged long ago. Understanding the existing culture is therefore the beginning of the exercise, not its conclusion.
Discovering What Makes an Organization Successful
At Cohesive Strategy Group, we wanted to approach our own values through the lens of experience. After more than four years, we had accumulated something we did not possess when we started: a meaningful history of client relationships, business decisions, challenges, and outcomes.
That experience gave us an opportunity to look beyond our original intentions. We could reflect on the work that had produced meaningful results and the behaviours that contributed to those outcomes. Equally important was the perspective of our clients. What did they consistently appreciate about working with us? What differentiated their experience with Cohesive Strategy Group? What had contributed to the trust and relationships we were able to build?
These questions helped us consider not simply what we believed was important, but what had demonstrably contributed to our effectiveness.
We believe this is an important distinction for any organization seeking to understand its values. Rather than beginning with a list of desirable qualities, leaders should examine the behaviours that have consistently contributed to their organization's success. Those behaviours provide a much stronger foundation for identifying what the organization genuinely values.
However, the discovery process requires more than identifying what has worked. Leaders must be willing to examine the organization critically, including questioning whether the behaviours it celebrates are truly responsible for its success.
A company may attribute its performance to its entrepreneurial culture when, in reality, favourable market conditions have played a significant role. Another may believe its responsiveness to customers is a competitive advantage without understanding the personal costs being absorbed by employees to deliver that responsiveness.
Success does not automatically validate every behaviour associated with it. The challenge is to distinguish between the behaviours that genuinely create lasting value and those that simply accompany successful outcomes.
Not Everything That Contributes to Success Deserves to Become a Value
This is where our philosophy requires an important qualification. When we say organizations should value the things that make them successful, we are not suggesting that every behaviour producing a positive business result should become a core value.
An organization can achieve exceptional short-term financial performance through behaviours that ultimately damage its long-term prospects. Excessive workloads might contribute to short-term productivity. Aggressive sales practices might produce immediate revenue. A demanding leadership style might deliver results while creating a culture of fear. None of these outcomes necessarily makes the underlying behaviour worth preserving.
The behaviours worth valuing are those that contribute to meaningful, sustainable success and reflect the kind of organization leadership is committed to building.
This introduces an element of deliberate choice. Discovering what has contributed to success is the starting point. Determining which of those behaviours deserves to be protected is a leadership responsibility.
Consider an organization that has built strong relationships by consistently putting the interests of its clients first. If that principle is genuinely a core value, it must influence decisions even when acting in the client's best interests means declining an opportunity to generate additional revenue.
That is when the value becomes meaningful. Values cannot be assessed solely by the benefits they produce. They must also be considered in terms of what an organization is prepared to sacrifice to uphold them.
This idea is consistent with the work of Jim Collins and Jerry Porras. In their influential ">Building Your Company's Vision, they argue that enduring core values are discovered through examining an organization's fundamental beliefs, rather than selected simply because they appear advantageous.
Their perspective adds an important dimension to our thinking. Although experience helps reveal which behaviours have contributed to success, the decision to preserve a value should not depend exclusively on its commercial benefit. Some principles deserve to be upheld because they represent fundamental convictions about how the organization should operate.
The true test of a company's values is not what they contribute when business is going well, but what leadership is prepared to sacrifice to uphold them when circumstances become difficult. A value may have contributed to an organization's success, but its authenticity becomes most evident when leadership remains committed to it even when doing so is uncomfortable.
Values Should Influence Choices, Not Simply Describe Behaviours
One of the most common weaknesses in organizational values is the gap between what a company says matters and what actually influences its decisions.
This is particularly relevant when values are treated primarily as a communications exercise. Organizations invest considerable effort in developing appealing language. Values are incorporated into websites, employee handbooks, and internal presentations. Yet the real test comes when those statements encounter operational reality.
If an organization claims its people are its greatest asset, how does that belief influence decisions when financial performance is under pressure? If it values transparency, how are employees treated when they raise concerns or challenge leadership? And if it values quality, what happens when maintaining that standard threatens an important deadline or customer relationship?
These are not simply questions about communication. They are questions about leadership accountability.
Values become meaningful when they influence what leaders choose to do, especially when competing priorities make the decision uncomfortable. An organization cannot credibly claim a commitment to its values while routinely making exceptions whenever those commitments become inconvenient. A value that never influences a difficult decision is worth questioning.
There is also an important relationship between values and strategy. Strategy requires an organization to make deliberate choices about where it will compete and how it intends to succeed. Those choices establish the organization's competitive direction. Values establish the behavioural principles within which those choices are pursued.
They are not substitutes for strategy, but they can influence the strategic options an organization is willing to consider.
Values should provide continuity without becoming an excuse to resist necessary change.
A company that genuinely values long-term customer relationships, for instance, may choose not to compete through practices that generate immediate revenue at the expense of client trust. That is a strategic trade-off informed by organizational values.
This relationship becomes particularly important as organizations grow or change direction. The strategy may evolve as markets shift and new opportunities emerge, but a clear understanding of organizational values can help leadership determine which behaviours and principles should remain consistent.
But What About Organizations That Are Just Starting Out?
An obvious challenge to our philosophy is that a new organization cannot operate for years without any guiding principles. We agree.
Founders should have a clear understanding of their personal convictions and the principles they want to bring into the business. Those beliefs can be instrumental in establishing expectations and shaping the early culture. However, we would distinguish between founding principles and demonstrated organizational values.
Founding principles represent what leadership believes should guide the organization. Demonstrated values reflect what the organization has consistently practised, learned, and chosen to preserve.
There is no reason an organization cannot begin with an initial set of guiding principles and refine its understanding as experience accumulates. In fact, that may be a more useful approach than treating the original list as permanent and unquestionable.
The distinction also creates an opportunity for leadership to assess whether its intentions are becoming reality. If a founding principle consistently fails to appear in the organization's behaviour, leaders need to understand why. The principle may require greater reinforcement, or the organization may need to reconsider whether it represents a genuine commitment.
At Cohesive Strategy Group, we did not believe there was a particular anniversary or milestone at which values should suddenly be established. We simply wanted enough experience to approach the exercise with substance.
For other organizations, the appropriate timing will differ. The more important consideration is the evidence supporting the values and the leadership commitment behind them.
From Discovery to Deliberate Commitment
Discovering organizational values is not the end of the process. If anything, it marks the beginning of a more demanding responsibility.
Once leadership has identified the behaviours that genuinely define the organization and contribute to its sustainable success, those behaviours must be deliberately reinforced. This is where values move beyond reflection and become an active part of organizational culture.
They should influence how people are recruited, how performance is evaluated, and how leaders respond when behaviours fall short of expectations. It is particularly important that senior leadership be held to the same standards. An organization cannot credibly claim a value applies to everyone while allowing exceptions for people who generate significant revenue or occupy influential positions.
Nor can it assume that values will remain embedded without attention as the organization grows.
Growth brings new employees, different leadership perspectives, and greater complexity. The informal behaviours that shaped a small organization do not necessarily transfer automatically to a larger one. Articulating values can help preserve what matters, but only when those values remain connected to decisions and the systems through which the organization operates.
Leadership must also be prepared to challenge established behaviours that are inconsistent with the organization's stated commitments. This can be uncomfortable, particularly when those behaviours are associated with individuals who have historically contributed to the company's success.
The willingness to address those inconsistencies is an important demonstration of how seriously leadership takes its values.
Ultimately, establishing company values should not be viewed as a project that concludes when the final wording is approved. The process of reinforcing those values, challenging behaviours that undermine them, and ensuring they remain relevant is an ongoing leadership responsibility.
The Question We Believe Leaders Should Ask
Our decision to establish Cohesive Strategy Group's values after more than four years was not an argument that every organization should wait. It reflected our belief that values deserve more consideration than simply selecting a list of desirable attributes.
We wanted ours to be grounded in what we had learned about our business, what our clients valued about working with us, and what we believed was important enough to preserve as we continued to grow.
We also recognize that documenting our values does not mean we have completed the work of living them. That responsibility continues through every decision we make.
For leaders considering their own organizational values, we would encourage a different starting point. Rather than asking only what values the organization should have, begin by understanding the behaviours that already define it. Examine what has contributed to its success, challenge assumptions about why that success occurred, and consider which behaviours deserve an enduring commitment.
Then ask whether the organization is prepared to uphold those commitments when circumstances make doing so difficult.
Ultimately, the most meaningful company values are not simply statements about what an organization wants to become. They represent what an organization has learned about itself, what it genuinely believes in, and what it is unwilling to compromise.